Theme: Right to Reside and Habitual Residence Condition
Period of Analysis: SWAO Annual Reports 2009-2020
Keywords: Habitual Residence Condition, Right to Reside
Casebase No. G0116
Summary of the relevant law:
The term “habitually resident” is not defined in Irish law. In practice it means that you have a proven close link to Ireland. The term also conveys permanence – that a person has been here for some time and intends to stay here for the foreseeable future.
The legislation providing for the habitual residence condition is contained in Section 246 of the Social Welfare Consolidation Action 2005 (as amended). However, Deciding Officers and Designated Persons must also have regard to S.I. No. 548/2015 – European Communities (Free Movement of Persons) Regulations 2015. , which deals with the right of residence for EU/EEA citizens and their families. Habitual residence in Ireland is a condition that you must satisfy for certain social welfare payments , for example Child Benefit. This condition took effect from 1 May 2004 and affects all applicants regardless of nationality.
With all social welfare payments in Ireland, you must satisfy the rules for each scheme to qualify.
Your spouse, civil partner or cohabitant and any dependent children you have are not required to satisfy the habitual residence condition in their own right. So if you apply for a social welfare payment only you, the applicant, has to satisfy the habitual residence condition.
Proving you are habitually resident relies heavily on fact. If you have lived in Ireland all your life, you will probably have no difficulty showing that you satisfy the factors which indicate habitual residence.
To satisfy the Habitual Residence Condition (HRC) you must:
Have the right to reside in the State AND
Show that you are habitually resident, having regard to all of your circumstances, including in particular the following which are set out in the legislation:
- the length and continuity of your residence in Ireland or in any other particular country
- the length and purpose of any absence from Ireland
- the nature and pattern of your employment
- your main centre of interest AND
- your future intentions as they appear from all the circumstances
These are sometimes called the “five factors”.
Who has the right to reside?
People who have a right to reside include:
- Irish nationals have a right of residence in Ireland;
- UK nationals coming in from the Common Travel Area (CTA) also have a right to reside here under the CTA agreement;
- EEA nationals who are employed or self-employed in Ireland have a right to reside;
- non-EEA nationals who have a residency or work permit to legally reside and work in the State, provided that there are no restrictions attached to that residency or work permit.
Permission to reside will generally be evidenced by an appropriate immigration stamp in the person’s passport, a letter of authorisation or a Certificate of Registration issued by the Garda National Immigration Bureau (GNIB), that is a GNIB card.
Key grounds of appeals by appellants:
The majority of the appeals are brought on the basis that the deciding/appeals officer erred in applying the correct legislation and/or legal grounds and erred in finding that the conditions of HRC were not met.
Observations on appeal outcomes:
Given that the majority of the appeals are brought on the basis that the deciding officer / appeals officer erred in finding that the criteria for ‘habitual resident’ was not been met, the appeals reported below focus principally on how the conditions of ‘habitually resident’ must be met and the application of the correct legislation.
In accordance with Section 246 of the 2005 Act establishing habitual residence is a two stage process which firstly requires that the person has a right to reside in the State. If it is established that the person has a right to reside, an assessment of their situation under 5 factors is carried out to determine their centre of interest and future intentions.
The reports below suggest that appellants are usually unsuccessful where they cannot establish a right to reside or on the basis of fact that they don’t fall under other factors to allow them to exercise this right. They further show that the majority of decisions may fall on the factual matrix of the particular case and the particular circumstances relevant to the person at issue.
 Regarding the right to reside of EU workers, see Casebase Report G0113 and Georgeta Voican v. Chief Appeals Officer, Social Welfare Appeals Office, Minister for Employment Affairs and Social Protection, Ireland and the Attorney General  No.748 J.R